In the illustrious year of 1956, the esteemed Stanley Matthews was the inaugural recipient of the European Footballer of the Year award. This coveted title, voted upon solely by journalists, was exclusively reserved for European players plying their trade at European clubs. This criterion regrettably excluded some of football’s most storied icons, such as Brazil’s legendary Pele and the enchanting Garrincha, from ever vying for the honor.

​

At the seasoned age of 41, Matthews was still a paragon of athleticism and skill for Blackpool and the England national team. His remarkable prowess on the field saw him triumph over formidable adversaries, namely Real Madrid’s majestic forward Alfredo di Stefano and Stade Reims’ illustrious frontman Raymond Kopa, to secure this landmark accolade.

​

The narrative, however, did not end there for Di Stefano and Kopa. Both players, revered for their extraordinary talents, soon etched their names into footballing lore. Di Stefano clinched the coveted award in 1957 and 1959, solidifying his legacy as one of the game's all-time greats. Meanwhile, Kopa, renowned for his visionary playmaking and scintillating performances, was celebrated with the honor in 1958, further affirming his status amongst the elite.

​

These achievements not only highlighted the individual brilliance of Matthews, Di Stefano, and Kopa but also underscored the evolving and expansive nature of football’s highest accolades. The exclusion of non-European players from contention was a poignant reminder of the times, leaving many to speculate how the dazzling exploits of Pele and Garrincha might have reshaped the award’s history.